The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Today's Front Page

February 28, 2013

House speaker, state chamber want study to make sure new appellate rules fair, efficient

By Mannix Porterfield Register-Herald Reporter

CHARLESTON — Informal chats in the business community say West Virginia’s new appellate rules are giving litigants an even playing field in the courts, but House Speaker Rick Thompson and the state Chamber of Commerce want to make sure that is the case.

Toward finding that answer, Thompson announced Wednesday the start of a year-long study to see if the system is fair and efficient.

Provided the Senate goes along with the House resolution, an interims study would be arranged by the Joint Committee on Government and Finance, the speaker pointed out.

Chamber President Steve Roberts applauded the bi-partisan move at a news conference and disparaged the “judicial hellhole” label that other groups have sought to apply to West Virginia’s legal system.

“I’m uncomfortable with that label,” Roberts said, when asked about the characterization.

“I’m curious as to what can be done to cause that to stop.”

Hours after the news conference, West Virginia Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse decried the call for a year-long study, saying this state is the only one witout an automatic right of appeal.

The group said Thompson and his House colleagues, along with some lobbyists, are ignoring the need for more legal system reforms.

“What’s the motivation here?” asked Greg Thomas, the group’s executive director.

“The personal injury lawsuit industry loves to have a state where there is no automatic appeal. It puts a gun to the head of defendants to settle or else gamble on the decision of a lower court on what may be very complicated legal issues, and it puts a fat wad of cash in the prsonal injury lawyers’ pockets.”

Within the past nine years, Roberts said the Legislature has enacted 16 legal reform bills, while the leadership has managed to begin retiring long-standing debts, lower taxes and provide fairer treatment to public employees.

“The consensus among people I talk to is West Virginia’s legal system is improving and I think that’s something we want to continue looking at and talking about,” Roberts said.

“The feedback we’re getting principally from the defense bar is that the rules adopted by the Supreme Court are working and they’re working very well.”

Thompson pointed out the new appellate rules were imposed by the bench after an independent commission led an exhaustive review of West Virginia’s civil justice system.

“We want to make sure that West Virginia courts are fair and impartial,” he said.

“We continue to hear from out-of-state companies and different organizations that West Virginia’s court system is not fair and impartial.”

In talking with the justices, the speaker said the high court feels its system is impartial to litigants.

“But it seems no matter what we do as a legislative body to improve our West Virginia system, including the creation of a new business court litigation system, which I was strongly for and championed, in spite of doing all that, we still get classified that we’re not fair, we’re not impartial,” Thompson said.

“So, we want to delve into the truth and see if the system is working and if these complaints are well-founded.”

The year-long examination will also tell legislative leaders if additional action is in order, the speaker said.

Anecdotal evidence passed on to him suggest the new rules are fair, Roberts said, but a formal look-see cannot hurt matters.

“To us, it only makes good sense to try to get to the bottom of this to take a look at the appeals that have already been issued, how the process is working and how those who are asking for appeals are reacting to the written appeals that they have been receiving.”

— E-mail: mannix@register-herald.com

Text Only
Today's Front Page
  • Importance of cardiac unit at RGH, concern over temporary closure expressed

    Dorothy Wright-Reynolds will remember Nov. 13, 2009, for the rest of her life.

    May 18, 2013

  • Fayette County Office of Emergency Services takes planning seriously

    Improving the county’s communications during a disaster is a top priority of the Fayette County Office of Emergency Services, says the agency’s new director.

    May 18, 2013

  • New trail in works for Hatfield-McCoy system

    Another addition to the Hatfield-McCoy Trail system in southern West Virginia is in the works.

    May 18, 2013

  • Students suspected in vandalism at Wayne High

    Wayne County’s Board of Education will meet to consider disciplining students suspected of vandalizing a high school.
     

    May 18, 2013

  • powerball Drawing tonight

    With an estimated Powerball Jackpot of $600 million, the largest prize in the game’s history and the world’s second largest lottery prize, many local residents are dreaming of how they would spend their fortune if they were to strike it rich.

    May 18, 2013 1 Photo

  • Details still ‘sketchy’ concerning shutdown of cardiac stent procedures at RGH

     The four-day suspension of heart stent procedures at Raleigh General Hospital due to an “unexpected availability of physician coverage” and without further explanation has left more questions than answers, answers that, according to hospital spokesman and Director of Marketing Kevin McGraw, will not be available until at least Monday.

    May 18, 2013

  • ticket 2013 Click-it Or Ticket campaign starts today

    Beckley Police Lt. Paul Blume wants to let motorists know that if they get pulled over in the Beckley area today, they’re getting a ticket.

    May 18, 2013 1 Photo

  • grad An Eye Toward the Future

    May 18, 2013 1 Photo

  • RGH suspends heart stent procedures until Monday

     Officials at Raleigh General Hospital issued a statement late Thursday afternoon indicating that “due to the unexpected unavailability of physician coverage,” cardiac stent procedures won’t be available to area residents at the Beckley facility until Monday, May 20.
     No other details were provided by hospital officials.
     Interventional cardiac care procedures were launched at RGH in November 2009 to serve a growing need for angioplasty lab services in Southern West Virginia.
     

    May 16, 2013

  • Thompson to depart house speaker post

    Rick Thompson is abandoning his post as speaker of the House of Delegates to accept a cabinet-level job in the Tomblin administration as head of the Department of Veterans Assistance.
    Thompson’s departure is likely to trigger a scramble to succeed him as speaker, with a number of Democrats expected to jockey for the post.

    May 16, 2013