Local News
Starcher: Property owners shafted in windfarm case
Justice Larry Starcher, who cast the lone dissenting vote in last month’s landmark windfarm 4-1 decision, believes Greenbrier County property owners are getting the shaft in regard to the $300 million Beech Ridge Energy Windfarm.
Starcher issued his two-page dissenting opinion last Tuesday and chided his colleagues for voting in favor of upholding two Public Service Commission decisions which gave Chicago-based Invenergy, the parent company of Beech Ridge, the green light to build over 100 wind turbines on forested ridges in northern Greenbrier County.
“I dissent because the Public Service Commission, and now the majority opinion, have decided that the formally adopted regulations of the Commission are more like ‘guidelines’ than ‘actual rules,’” Starcher wrote. “For instance, even though the Commission’s regulation’s require a utility to provide certain information (such as information about historical sites affected by a utility project) to the Commission before a permit is issued, the majority’s opinion now allows that information to be provided after the permit is issued — ostensibly because that information is not important to the permit application process.”
Starcher then echoed an argument made by both anti-windfarm opponents which filed suit against the PSC’s decision.
“... if the information is not critical to the permit application process, then why do the Commission’s regulations require that the information be produced?”
Starcher said the case should have been “remanded to the Commission for further study,” and he would have required Beech Ridge to “produce all of the legally required information about the impact of wind turbines on the neighboring property and aesthetic values.”
“When the PSC authorizes the construction of gigantic industrial wind turbines in some of the most beautiful countryside of our State, I think that the Commission has a duty to fully take into account the effect of the turbines on the property values of adjoining and nearby landowners and communities,” Starcher wrote. “... before issuing any permits, the Commission must require a utility seeking to build wind turbines to produce all of the information that is required by law or regulation.
“Before the State sanctions both private property values and the aesthetic value of beautiful landscapes, the public utility must publicly demonstrate the scope of injury as part of the record before the Commission grants any permits.”
— E-mail: cgiggenbach@register-herald.com
- Local News
-
- Additional warrants issued in home invasion
-
Rahall mulls health care vote
With a decision looming Sunday, U.S. Reps. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., and Rick Boucher, D-Va., said they both are still undecided on the $940 billion health care overhaul bill.
-
Local woman, doctor weigh in on the need for health care
It was a mere month ago that Deborah Cox was working as a nurse in fairly good health.
Today, the 51-year-old says her life is upside down because of a leukemia diagno - What's Happening — March 20, 2010
-
Big Sandy looking for charities, nonprofits
All Big Sandy locations will donate to charities that sign up beforehand if customers mention that charity when making a purchase of $499 or more on March 25.
-
SCHOOL CLOSINGS and DELAYS
Click HERE to go to the West Virginia Department of Education with up-to-date school closings and delays by county.
-
Improvements under way to make Bluestone Dam safer
Improvements and repairs planned at Bluestone Dam over the next 10 years will make the structure safer, but new operating procedures could lead to increased flooding in some areas downstream from the dam, officials said Thursday at a public meeting in Hinton.
-
DOH to relocate cemeteries for expressway
West Virginia Division of Highways officials will begin relocating cemeteries next week to make room for the next phase of the Coalfields Expressway.
-
GVEDC board gets training
Jeff Finkle, president and CEO of the International Economic Development Council (IEDC), spent several hours with local development officials Thursday, giving pointers and leading a discussion on economic strategies.
-
Mix-up leads to W.Va. couple on wrong ballot
Stan and Janet Norman are running for office whether they like it or not.
- More Local News Headlines
