subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Mon, Dec 01 2008 

Published: November 15, 2006 06:43 pm    print this story   email this story  

No proof slurry is harming water, DEP hydrologist says

Mannix Porterfield
Register-Herald Reporter

CHARLESTON — An industry leader says West Virginia lawmakers need to spend extra cash generated by the coal boom to install more water and sewer lines, rather than usurp the court’s power in a dispute over water in Mingo County that some residents insist was soiled by mining practices.

Witnesses went before Judiciary Subcommittee B in a two-hour hearing Wednesday to say slurry injections in worked-out deep mines are rigidly monitored and must pass through a stringent permitting process.

Last month, coalfield residents displayed jars filled with contaminated water taken from the Lick Creek area, blaming it for a variety of disorders from frequent dental problems to liver malfunctions.

In the latest go-round, however, George Jenkins, a hydrologist with the Department of Environmental Protection, told the panel no proof has emerged to link dirty water with slurry, the mushy substance that results when water is mixed with coal in a cleaning process to prepare it for the market.

“Scientific evidence doesn’t back that up,” he told lawmakers. “We’re not seeing that those slurry things are the contaminants.”

Jenkins suggested metallic particles naturally seep into water wells, along with other matter, and for that reason such sources of water must be cleaned out on a regular basis to keep them free of contaminants.

“People don’t understand, but you have to maintain wells just like your car,” he said.

Jenkins said water within a half-mile radius is constantly monitored during the permitting process.

“You know that water doesn’t necessarily stop within a half-mile radius,” Delegate Robert Tabb, D-Jefferson, said.

Chad Board, a groundwater supervisor for the DEP, told the committee all slurry permits must meet federal safe water standards, and no injections are allowed within a quarter mile of a private water system. No fuels are permitted in the injection process, he said.

Time expired before the panel could hear from Chris Hamilton, vice president of the West Virginia Coal Association, but afterward, he said the Mingo County issue “appears to be a very isolated issue.”

Hamilton alluded to testimony that contaminated water isn’t a problem statewide, but is “very localized,” and in that instance is in litigation.

“Which causes me to question the appropriateness of this matter being before this committee or the Legislature,” the industry leader said.

A number of lawmakers recalled the testimony of October’s witnesses, causing Hamilton to criticize the process.

“And we did not hear objective scientists speak last month,” he said. “What we heard, in fact, were paid consultants and expert witnesses for the petitioners in this matter that’s currently being litigated in Mingo County.”

Hamilton said he was struck by government officials telling the panel that impoundments and slurry systems undergo “some of the more stringent requirements found anywhere in the nation or, for that matter, the world.

“They’re carefully engineered, carefully and continuously monitored and heavily regulated,” he said.

Hamilton acknowledged a problem with Mingo’s water but said a public system is being installed.

Rather than sit in place of the judicial system, Hamilton suggested the committee look into the prospects of spending “all the current surpluses generated by the high energy market and high coal prices to invest every single penny of that surplus into drinking water and for sewer projects around the state.”

“We have an unacceptable percentage of our residents without fresh drinking water and, in many instances, these are in rural areas where there’s no mining within close proximity,” Hamilton said.

Hamilton challenged the committee to change course and look for ways of making public water accessible to all West Virginians.

In December’s interims, Hamilton said he would be willing to appear before the panel to expound on Jenkins’ findings.

“If they want to substitute themselves for the judicial branch of government, we will bring our expert witnesses ...” he added.

William Orem, a research geochemist for the U.S. Geological Survey in Reston, Va., testified about high incidences of kidney dysfunction and renal cancer in other states, notably the Powder River Basin in Wyoming, but no such link has been established in West Virginia.

“We’re not saying it does not occur,” he told the panel. “We’re saying, ‘Let’s look at it and see what’s there.’”

— E-mail:

mannix@register-herald.com

print this story   email this story  



monster
wheels

Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

EXTENSION AGENT
West Virginia University. *Career Opportunity*
West Virginia University Extension Service is recruiting for a tenur
...>MORE

MINING POSITIONS - BROOKS RUN MINING CO.
Brooks Run Mining Company. Running Right. “My dad and I both work for Brooks Run. And now my wife and I feel that Brooks...>MORE

INSURANCE CALL CENTER POSITIONS
The right atmosphere. Determination to win. Long term stability. Winning business. That’s what we’re committed to! We’re...>MORE

INSURANCE SALES ASSOCIATES
Insurance Sales Associates. TRG Insurance Solutions has the best local opportunity for inside insurance agents. We repre...>MORE

AUTOCAD DRAFTER / TECHNICIAN
Autocad drafter / technician. Coal Mining Company, a leader in producing high quality metallurgical coal in central east...>MORE

MINING PROFESSIONALS - KANAWHA EAGLE
Mining professionals needed. Certified Foremen, Equipment Operators, and Certified Electricians. Kanawha Eagle / Newtow...>MORE

INSIDE SALES ASSOCIATE
Inside Sales Associate position, Beckley, WV. HVAC distributor seeking an energetic individual with initiative for a ful...>MORE

ELECTRICIANS, SUPERVISORS, OPERATORS & GENERAL LABORERS
Remington, LLC, an operating affiliate of Patriot Coal Corporation's Magnum Coal Company, is seeking resumes for electri...>MORE

INFORMATION SYSTEMS MANAGER, STUDENT PROGRAM ADVISOR, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
New River Community and Technical College, with multiple campuses in southeast WV, invites candidates for the following ...>MORE

RN / COUNCIL ON AGING
The Council on Aging is currently accepting applications for the position of RN in the Itmann office to work with the Pe...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Jobs

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index