subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Sep 06 2008 

Published: July 13, 2008 10:35 pm    print this story   email this story  

Prison smoke ban impractical, lawmaker says

Perry: Study shows smoking by inmates has ‘calming effect’

Mannix Porterfield
Register-Herald Reporter

CHARLESTON — The intent was to get inmates unhooked from tobacco and, over the long haul, lower West Virginia’s medical bills by not having to treat them for nicotine-related illnesses.

Yet, if letters sent by inmates to media and one legislative leader are accurate, the smoking ban isn’t working.

Cigarettes have become the hot new item of contraband, and it’s a seller’s market in the black market behind prison walls.

Delegate Dave Perry, D-Fayette, a co-chairman of the Legislature’s Oversight Committee on Regional Jail and Correctional Authority, thinks inmates should be able to indulge in West Virginia prisons, providing some variations can be found in bans imposed in counties where the facilities are located.

He has one word for the ban imposed by Corrections Commissioner Jim Rubenstein last March 1 — “impractical.”

“I have received similar information (from inmates), that the price for a cigarette in prison is greater now than what the price was for illegal drugs, that it’s just not working,” Perry said.

Perry referred to a study performed in Kentucky that suggested smoking by inmates was a form of relief from the pressures of being cooped up in cells.

“It had a calming effect,” the delegate said, summarizing the findings.

“There was an indirect, I won’t say medical value, but indirect value achieved. You’ve got a population where there’s only so much release they can have as well as employees. Employees are under the same intense pressure cooker as everyone else. By the same token, adherence would be expected until at such time some variation or some exceptions would be permissible legally within county codes.”

Perry and his fellow panelists on the interims committee are awaiting a report this month from Rubenstein on various smoking bans imposed in counties where correctional facilities are located.

For instance, one in Fayette County, which embraces Mount Olive Correctional Complex, forbids smoking on any public property. Presumably, it would mean that even employees couldn’t light up on the grounds of MOCC. That ordinance is on hold, however, until Oct. 1.

Rubenstein is scheduled to spell out before Perry’s committee in the July 27-29 interims just how each county smoking ordinance is applicable to the prisons they embrace within their jurisdictions.

“It would seem to indicate they would,” Perry said. “That’s why the question was asked. The inquiry was made to see if any variations to that are allowable or not allowable. That’s why the clarification is being sought.”

Although a nonsmoker, Perry says he can understand why smoking inmates think the policy is one-sided, since they are denied access to nicotine but correctional officers and other employees may continue to smoke on the job.

“My feel is that it (policy) needs to be reasonably applied and take into consideration both constituencies, or both parties — smokers and nonsmokers,” he said.

“Should a smoker impose his values on a smoker and should a nonsmoker impose his values on a smoker? I think that things need to be written and facilitated so as to identify both populations.”

Perry doesn’t believe, however, that the committee can override Rubenstein’s policy.

And that’s where the individual smoking ordinances will come into play.

“I think the county ordinances need to be looked at and there need to be variations and exceptions for individual situations,” he said.

“I don’t think you can make one policy, or one variance, that covers everything. You can’t put it all under one umbrella.”

— E-mail:

mannix@register-herald.com





print this story   email this story  



monster
wheels

Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENGINEER
Pittsburgh company is seeking full time Structural / Civil Engineer for its Beckley, WV office. Responsible for analysis...>MORE

ELECTRICIANS, *ME0'S, ROOF BOLTERS
Pocahontas Coal Company is seeking the following positions: Experienced Underground: * ELECTRICIANS, * MEO’S, * ROOF BO...>MORE

INSURANCE CALL CENTER POSITIONS
The right atmosphere. Determination to win. Long term stability. Winning business. That’s what we’re committed to! We’re...>MORE

TRANSPORTATION SPECIALIST
Infinity Coal Sales, LLC. Transportation Specialist. Infinity Coal Sales, LLC, an affiliate of Magnum Coal Company, is s...>MORE

EQUIPMENT OPERATORS, ELECTRICIANS
Now hiring for Pineville and Welch area. Equipment Operators $22-24 per hour. Electricians $10,000 monthly salary. Forem...>MORE

JOB FAIR - COLUMBIA FOREST PRODUCTS
Columbia Forest Products. Employment Opportunities.
In anticipation of future hiring, Columbia Forest Products, a p
...>MORE

MINER OPERATORS & ELECTRICIANS
Underground Mining Positions. Speed Mining, LLC, an operating affiliate of Magnum Coal Company, has immediate openings f...>MORE

MINING POSITIONS - NORTH STAR ONE
Pocahontas Coal Company’s North Star One Surface and High Wall Miner operations located near Beckley, WV is seeking qual...>MORE

CHIEF UNDERGROUND ENGINEER
Nicholas Energy, an expanding operation located at Drennen, WV is now accepting resumes for the position of Chief Underg...>MORE

SALES ASSISTANT
Local company has a position open for an Inside Sales Assistant. Duties to include handling parts calls efficiently and ...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Jobs

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index