subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Wed, Feb 10 2010 

Published: March 31, 2007 11:09 pm    print this story  

Group seeking ‘code of ethics’ for medical witnesses

By Mannix Porterfield
Register-Herald Reporter

In one celebrated case involving an asbestos-related claim against CSX Corp., the plaintiff’s lawyer in the Huntington civil trial produced a physician as a medical expert on behalf of his client.

But suddenly, when the defense began checking into matters, a mystery developed.

His name was markedly absent from the list of doctors maintained by three medical licensing agencies.

Alarmed by that, the defense decided to examine the personal data of the “expert” witness.

An address on Fifth Avenue in Huntington assigned to the man on court documents turned out to be an empty lot. His telephone number actually had belonged to a woman since 1994.

“They had clearly fabricated the name of this certifying physician,” says Steve Cohen, executive director of Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse.

“There was a case in Ohio County recently in which an expert witness hadn’t practiced medicine in 10 years.”

Cohen alluded to those examples to highlight an overall study performed by the Center for Survey Research at the University of Virginia.

In its study, the center learned most doctors in West Virginia doubt the “expert” testimony if it is given beyond a physician’s specialty or is motivated by money.

Sixty-four percent of doctors surveyed rated the overall quality of expert witnesses as “poor” or “only fair.” Only 27 percent felt it was “good.” And a mere 9 percent considered it “very good” or “excellent.”

The survey found 72 percent had seen or heard testimony by a medical expert they felt was either in error or based on questionable science.

All but 5 percent agreed that testimony as supportive diagnoses provided for a fee was tainted.

Four in five thought medical expert testimony had a negative impact on the integrity of their profession.

Cohen plans to present the research to both the West Virginia State Bar and the state Legislature, hopefully to inspire some reforms.

Specifically, he’d like to see a “code of ethics” created to prevent misleading testimony given in the name of science.

“The Legislature could require standards for so-called expert testimony in civil cases,” Cohen said.

“The bar could do it, but the Legislature could mandate certain minimum standards for expert testimony.”

One physician, Dr. Gregory Saracco of Wheeling, a former president of the Ohio County Medical Society and a leading player in the 2001 medical malpractice reforms enacted by the Legislature, views the survey as a springboard for change.

“Misleading, inaccurate, certainly fraudulent testimony from medical experts speaking outside their field of expertise or testifying for a financial incentive have no place in West Virginia courts, or any court for that matter,” Saracco said.

“Such testimony would bring a miscarriage of justice and erode the credibility of our profession. Juries must have the truth from reliable experts if our courts are to be fair.”

Federal guidelines could serve as a pattern for state policymakers and members of the bar, he suggested.

“Junk science cannot be allowed in our courts,” the doctor said.

“There must be no tolerance for testimony that is pure science fiction, which leads to frivolous lawsuits and an outright abuse of the court system.”

A code of ethics was supported by 96 percent of the physicians interviewed in the University of Virginia research. And 94 percent felt that payment for expert testimony that hinges on the outcome of a case wasn’t ethical.

“Too often, a personal injury lawyer will present a so-called expert to try to put the appearance of a stamp of authority on what may be a factually baseless case,” Saracco said.

“It not only damages the integrity of law, it undermines patient confidence in the medical profession.”

— E-mail: mannix@register-herald.com

print this story  



autoconx

Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

ELK RUN JOB FAIR 2/12 - OAK HILL
Job FAIR. Massey Energy is accepting experienced underground applicants. Our expanding operations are located in Raleigh...>MORE

NURSES - CARELINK
NURSES Quality Improvement Coordinator / HEDIS. Nurses needed for HEDIS project February through May. Make appointments,...>MORE

SAFETY MANAGER
LOCAL Engineering Company with background in the coal industry is seeking a full-time Safety Manager. Detailed knowledge...>MORE

PLANT FOREMAN AND PLANT MAINTENANCE CHIEF
Nicholas Energy is accepting applications and resumes for Plant Foreman and Plant Maintenance Chief. If you are looking ...>MORE

INDUSTRIAL TIRE / MINE TIRE PRESSMAN
Industrial Tire / Mine Tire pressman needed - skilled tire tech to operate press equipment used to service underground m...>MORE

CERTIFIED SURFACE MINE ELECTRICIANS
Republic Energy is accepting applications and resumes for certified surface mine electricians. Experience with electric ...>MORE

DIRECTOR OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, WEBMASTER AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS SPECIALIST
LEWISBURG, WV - The West Virginia School of Osteopathic Medicine is currently hiring for several IT positions: Director ...>MORE

UNDERGROUND COAL MINING POSITIONS - MAMMOTH
MAMMOTH COAL, a subsidiary of Massey Energy is accepting experienced underground applicants. Our expanding operations ar...>MORE

PHYSICIAN ASSISTANT - NORTHERN GREENBRIER HEALTH CLINIC
Northern Greenbrier Health Clinic, Inc., headquartered in Williamsburg, WV has the following employment opportunity avai...>MORE

COAL MINING POSITIONS - SPEED MINING
Speed Mining, LLC, an operating affiliate of Patriot Coal Corporation, has immediate openings at its American Eagle Mine...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Jobs

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index