subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Feb 09 2010 

Published: February 19, 2009 09:56 pm    print this story  

Pros, cons of bottle bill presented to panel

By Mannix Porterfield
Register-Herald reporter

CHARLESTON — The script hasn’t changed, nor have the players.

Which leaves one big question: Is this year’s version of the bottle bill in West Virginia destined for the same fate as the preceding six losing proposals?

In Thursday’s presentation before a joint meeting of two House committees, a leading proponent of imposing a redeemable deposit on all beverage containers outlined the good that can come from it.

Johh Ferrari, president of NexCycle’s operations in California, touted bottle laws as effective in reducing roadside litter, creating jobs and inspiring recycling, as well as deterring consumers from dumping other forms of trash on highways.

“Jobs — and this is the important one,” Ferrari said.

With a slide presentation, Ferrari said beverage container laws led to 4,684 new jobs in Michigan, 3,800 in New York, 1,806 in Maine and between 250 and 350 in Vermont.

Eleven states have enacted such laws, and figures showed 69 to 74 percent of container litter had been reduced while overall discarded refuse was cut back 34 to 64 percent.

If West Virginia adopts such legislation, he promised, his firm will create a market here for recycled glass.

But afterward, Greg Sayre, head of the Independent Recyclers Association in Char-leston, maintained the math is fatally flawed in West Virginia’s proposal.

“If 60 percent of the people redeem their deposits, maybe you make it,” he said.

Redemption centers get 3 cents per container, the recycler gets a share and the consumer is due 10 cents for the deposit paid, he said.

“Our feeling is the bill is about $50 million short on funds,” Sayre said.

“So where does that money come from? It’s going to have to come from general revenue. There’s not enough money. If you look at the Michigan bottle bill or the California bottle bill, the deposits don’t cover all the costs.”

If only 60 percent of consumers cash in the used containers, the program might survive, he said. Above that threshold, he maintained, the program is headed for red ink and taxpayers at large will be forced to bail it out.

Another complaint is fraud, and Ferrari acknowledged some try to exploit the program with bottles bought in from other states, but this problem only figures into 2 to 3 percent.

“It has proven very successful,” Ferrari said of the California program.

That law imposes 5 cents per containers of less than 24 ounces and 10 cents for larger drinks.

Since its inception, he said, the California program has fed an underground economy to supplement low-income residents. For some folks, that is the sole source of income.

“You do not see a container on the side of the road in California,” he said.

Bottle laws spawn jobs at redemption centers for truck drivers and the processing of material, he said, while reducing the drain on energy to create new containers.

A coalition of opponents passed out a sheet to lawmakers and media personnel attacking the legislation, offered in the House by Delegate Barbara Fleischauer, D-Monongalia, and Sen. Dan Foster, D-Kanawha.

The paper maintained containers make up only 7.4 percent of all litter, the state cannot meet the refunds and that such a law would drive consumers and their money out of state.

More than 5 percent of total sales would be forfeited in border counties, the coalition maintained.

Members of the coalition included the West Virginia Retailers Association, Oil Marketers and Grocers Association, Teamsters Local Union No. 175, Anheuser-Busch and the West Virginia Beverage Association.

— E-mail: mannix@register-herald.com

print this story  



autoconx

Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

COMMERCIAL TIRE SERVICE MANAGER
Commercial Tire Service Manager in the Crab Orchard, WV area. Candidate must have a minimum of 5 years medium commercial...>MORE

AUDIT INSPECTORS
WV STATE AUDITOR’S OFFICE is seeking Audit Inspectors to perform financial statement audits on political subdivisions in...>MORE

COAL MINING POSITIONS - SPEED MINING
Speed Mining, LLC, an operating affiliate of Patriot Coal Corporation, has immediate openings at its American Eagle Mine...>MORE

INDUSTRIAL TIRE / MINE TIRE PRESSMAN
Industrial Tire / Mine Tire pressman needed - skilled tire tech to operate press equipment used to service underground m...>MORE

LOVE THE OUTDOORS? NATURE?
LOVE THE OUTDOORS? NATURE? HUNTING? FISHING? PEOPLE? SALES?Expanding, established land development co. in the Clarksburg...>MORE

PHYSICIAN ASSISTANT - NORTHERN GREENBRIER HEALTH CLINIC
Northern Greenbrier Health Clinic, Inc., headquartered in Williamsburg, WV has the following employment opportunity avai...>MORE

CERTIFIED SURFACE MINE ELECTRICIANS
Republic Energy is accepting applications and resumes for certified surface mine electricians. Experience with electric ...>MORE

DIRECTOR OF NURSING - THE BRIER NURSING HOME
Director of Nursing. Long Term Care facility looking for a Full time Director of Nursing. Must have a valid Registered N...>MORE

CNAS - MONTGOMERY GENERAL ELDERLY CARE
Montgomery GENERAL ELDERLY CARE is accepting applications / resumes for Certified Nursing Assistants. Applicants may app...>MORE

STORE ATTENDANT
Now taking applications for Store Attendant. This position is responsible for the movement of furniture in the store, l...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Jobs

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index