Manchin showed poor judgment
Sen. Manchin: “But if you’re going to be against me and target me, it would be nice if you tell me why.”
The debate about the veracity of statements made by the NRA vs. statements made by proponents of “Gun Control” is a trivial side issue, in my opinion. As I see it, the important issue is: Would the Manchin bill materially decrease the number of homicides by firearms in the U.S.? The answer is no.
Sen. Manchin showed poor judgment in working so hard on a non-solution to the murder-by-firearms problem.
Present laws requiring information from prospective purchasers of firearms are almost completely unenforced. Liars are not prosecuted.
So, first: enforce existing laws. Pass a bill requiring it, Sen. Manchin; that would help some.
Second: (very difficult, admittedly) restrain individuals prone to violence before they act. As a start, define the characteristics of the most violence-prone mental abnormalities. Second, identify the individuals suffering these characteristics. Third, enter these individuals in a prior restraint database. Forth, continuously monitor and, if necessary, institutionalize those individuals, on a case-by-case basis.
If these prescriptions are too draconian to contemplate in a free society, then let us stop wringing our hands and admit that the citizenry at large will have to continue to live with the present level of “random” killings. Certain populations can be protected (imperfectly, to be sure). For example, implement the NRA’s policy of armed guards in all schools, as is done in private schools attended by prominent politician’s children in the Washington, D.C., area.
Manchin showed poor judgment
- Our Readers Speak
Submit your opinion to Our Readers Speak section
The Register-Herald welcomes your opinion. Please e-mail your letters, through your computer's mail program, to firstname.lastname@example.org or via the postal service to: Our Readers Speak, P.O. Box 2398, Beckley, WV 25802.
Our Readers Speak — Wednesday, December 11, 2013
Drivers need to know distracted driving law
Proud of Greenbrier West football team
Our Readers Speak — Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2013
Wagon thief should rethink lifestyle
Football ‘experts’ should be patient
Our Readers Speak — Sunday, Dec. 8, 2013
Counsel could have avoided pool problem
Our Readers Speak — Friday, December 6, 2013
Why are gas prices so high in Beckley?
Here’s why I think gas is so high here
Washington to blame for coal’s slowdown
Our Readers Speak — Wednesday, Dec. 4, 2013
Let’s remember the reason for the season
Thank you for donation of gloves and hats
- Our Readers Speak — Friday, Nov. 29, 2013
Our Readers Speak — Tuesday, November 26, 2013
DNR needs to expand deer, bear hunting
You, too, can pardon a turkey for Thanksgiving
Our Readers Speak — Sunday, Nov. 24, 2013
Thanks for fundraisers to help fight cancer
Our Readers Speak — Saturday, November 23, 2013
Citizens should speak out on several topics
Lewisburg gas price needs investigated
- More Our Readers Speak Headlines
- Submit your opinion to Our Readers Speak section