The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Latest News

May 5, 2013

Judge rejects settlement in alleged rape case

Claims against a teacher listed in the suit thrown out

— A federal judge has rejected a $65,000 settlement offer in a case involving the alleged rape of a young girl at the former Mount Hope High School, while at the same time throwing out negligence claims against one of the teachers originally listed in the suit.

U.S. District Judge Joseph R. Goodwin rejected the settlement April 22 under the advisement of the girl’s guardian ad litem, appointed to represent her interests in litigation.

Maryl Sattler, the guardian, wrote in an April 19 filing with the court that she had “serious reservations” about the proposed settlement.

She says the current settlement does not cover the costs of future psychological care or private schooling and does not adequately compensate her for her suffering. Only about $34,000 would remain of the $65,000 after attorney’s fees.

The civil suit was brought forward in 2011 by Stephen and Sharon Endicott of Pax, the girl’s biological grandparents and adoptive parents.

The alleged rape of a 13-year-old girl referred to by her initials, B.E., in court documents, occurred Nov. 12, 2010, at the high school. She asserts that after school, five members of the high school basketball team forced her into a stairwell and raped and physically and sexually assaulted her in the presence of another female student.

“This young student has been dealt a grave injustice by the Fayette County Prosecutor’s office by not prosecuting the five young men and by the Fayette County Board of Education for not providing her a safe environment and a quality education,” a committee calling itself Justice for Bailey recently told The Register-Herald in an e-mail.

In an order filed Wednesday, Goodwin also granted a motion for summary judgment to defendant Linda Nevi, who was accused of negligence for her alleged role in the event.

Nevi was B.E.’s cheerleading coach. The plaintiffs claim that Nevi had asked the girl to help assemble cheerleading uniforms, which took so much time that she missed her bus.

However, the defense submitted video evidence it said proved that B.E. left Nevi’s office before school recessed. And depositions showed that B.E. stayed after school intentionally with a friend.

The judge concluded that Nevi “had no connection to B.E.’s presence at the school after hours.”

On the other hand, the court says there is still a big question about whether boys basketball coach Bo Morrison should have been supervising the boys who were allegedly involved in the rape.

The principal and vice principal — Mike and Leah Hutchins — also still face charges of negligence for not ensuring students were adequately supervised. Evidence shows that they were aware of disciplinary and behavior problems in the school’s hallways, the judge wrote, after a state audit said as much.

Evidence suggests that students used unsupervised areas of the school as spaces to have sex; condoms and semen were found in classrooms and in the stairwell where the assault occurred.

“It does not appear from the record that policies were put in place to ensure that students present after school hours were safe from student-on-student assault,” wrote Goodwin.

Several of the students accused of attacking B.E. had disciplinary records that included harassment, physical assault, inappropriate touching and punching out a window.

The Endicotts’ Title IX claims against both the Fayette County Board of Education and the West Virginia Department of Education have survived the summary judgment motion stage.

B.E. — an honor roll student, cheerleading captain and member of the homecoming court — claims that after the events of Nov. 12, 2010, she faced harassment at school, that no alternative education was provided by the school system and that the hostile environment deprived her of educational and extracurricular opportunities.

“One of the assailants was allowed to return to school where he resumed his scholastic career and availed himself to all benefits and programs the Board would offer him,” wrote the plaintiff’s lawyers in a supplemental memo to the court.

“Even today he is a school basketball star. By contrast, the plaintiff was vilified, ridiculed, humiliated and attacked upon returning to school.”

The plaintiffs say that a teacher sent by the county to the Endicotts’ home for homebound education, Jean R. Garrett, is related to one of the accused attackers and inappropriately discussed the case with B.E. When they complained, they say they were never provided with another instructor and were forced to go to Raleigh County for schooling.

In 2011, the Fayette County Prosecuting Attorney’s office chose not to bring criminal claims against the alleged rapists, saying that the girl recanted.

In October 2011, former Assistant Prosecutor Matthew England told The Register-Herald that B.E. had taken back her original claim that one of the boys had sexual intercourse with her, saying she was only forced into oral sex. Oral sex is also considered sexual intercourse under West Virginia law.

“It’s been really difficult to try to determine what exactly happened,” said England. “There were just so many inconsistencies and then with the victim recanting the significant portion of what she initially told law enforcement, it just left us with insufficient evidence to go forward.”

Nevertheless, he wrote in a letter to the Fayette County Board of Education that “medical evidence supports (B.E.’s) allegations of sexual intercourse.”

Testimony of the girl’s friend, who was with her at the time of the alleged assault, also corroborates that a sexual assault occurred.

In her filing, Sattler writes that “it is common for victims of sexual assault to recant in stressful situations.”

The recant, which Sattler said may have been a misunderstanding between B.E. and England, was one of the major reasons a criminal charge was not pursued.

But a medical specialist testified that “Individuals of this age who are sexually assaulted almost — well, more times than not, recant, especially when they come under social pressure.”

A pretrial conference is scheduled for Monday, with a jury trial set for Aug. 26.

— E-mail: cmoore@register-herald.com

1
Text Only
Latest News
  • legion VIDEO: American Legion posts plan to merge

    To help deal with its decreasing membership numbers, Beckley American Legion Post 70 is planning a merger with Post 32.

    “We see the benefit for both of us and for Raleigh County,” Post 32 Adjutant Frank Cook said. “Right now Post 70 is having membership problems and with membership problems comes financial problems.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • Tri-state coal interests rally before hearings

     More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia joined top state elected officials Wednesday to rally against proposed stricter federal pollution regulations for coal-burning power plants.

    July 31, 2014

  • legal Tort reform group brings message to Beckley

    How can West Virginia create more jobs and have a better business climate, at no cost to taxpayers?

    Greg Thomas, executive director of the West Virginia Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse (WV CALA), says legal reform is one of the answers to that question.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • ‘Biscuit guy’ makes his mark with anthem at TWV

    The old saying “being at the right place at the right time” couldn’t be more true for Calvin Alexander.

    Thanks to a salad dressing bottle (and some impressive vocal skills), Alexander was invited to sing the national anthem not once, but twice, at Theatre West Virginia before the opening of “Hatfields and McCoy

    July 31, 2014

  • Judge in W.Va. asked to delay gay marriage ruling

    Attorney General Patrick Morrisey has asked a judge to postpone ruling on a federal lawsuit challenging West Virginia's same-sex marriage ban until the U.S. Supreme Court reviews a ruling in a similar case in Virginia.

    July 30, 2014

  • Tri-state coal interests rally before EPA hearings

    More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia joined top state elected officials Wednesday to rally against proposed stricter federal pollution regulations for coal-burning power plants.

    July 30, 2014

  • Work continues on stand-alone Warrior Trail

    The executive director of the Hatfield and McCoy Trail Authority said Tuesday that officials are still working toward the creation of the stand-alone Warrior Trail in McDowell County.

    July 30, 2014

  • East River Mountain Tunnel repairs will continue for several weeks

    Motorists traveling Interstate 77 could see slight delays again tonight as repair work continues inside of the fire-damaged East River Mountain Tunnel.

    July 30, 2014

  • State leaders to attend coal rally in Pittsburgh

    West Virginia officials are set to join hundreds of coal miners and coal supporters at an electricity and energy jobs rally.

    July 30, 2014

  • Americans continue to be plagued by debt

    Credit card debt may have reached its lowest level in a decade, but according to a recent study on personal debt vs. income, just as more people are paying off their credit card debt monthly, nearly the same number of people are being reported for unpaid bills. 

    July 30, 2014