The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Latest News

March 5, 2012

Online sessions move state toward more transparent government

CHARLESTON — West Virginians won’t have to be at the Capitol this week to keep tabs on the Legislature as the 2012 regular session heads toward its midnight Saturday climax.

Anyone with Internet access can listen live to floor sessions as well as committee meetings for both the Senate and House of Delegates. Even some smartphones can link to this streaming audio.

Robert Phipps, a professional technologist at West Virginia University, said he’ll check the online audio if a bill or issue comes up that he’s interested in.

“If I can catch it, I will listen to the committee hearings or the floor fight if there is one,” said Phipps.

The 40-year-old said he has several friends who do the same. The House first went online in 2010. The Senate followed last year. Phipps said he tuned in to the debates that marked the opening days and weeks of the Senate’s 2011 session. With then-Senate President Earl Ray Tomblin acting as governor, senators sought a stand-in leader. The Senate ended up adopting rules that allowed for an acting president, but not without lengthy debate and lingering opposition by several members.

Phipps said that with only so many column inches in a newspaper and floor speeches reduced to sound bites, the audio fleshes out these proceedings.

“The Legislature comes out looking better,” Phipps said. “It gives you a better idea of what’s going on.”

He’s also a big fan of the Legislature’s extensive website.

It hosts the audio while offering an array of other features including committee schedules, a listing of legislation up for votes and the text, roll calls and chronology of actions on bills. Lawmakers in both chambers have begun discussing expanding the site further to offer video access.

House Majority Leader Brent Boggs said that delegates have begun looking at available technology, and how that technology’s been changing, as they consider ways to wire the House Chamber and committee rooms for video. The Braxton County Democrat also said this process may take some time, but that constituents have reacted with enthusiasm to the audio access in the meantime. Schools also appear to be tapping the online streaming for government and other classes, he said.

“I’ve heard so many positive comments, and not a single negative comment,” Boggs said.

All state legislatures now broadcast floor proceedings either online or on TV, according to a 2011 review by the National Conference of State Legislatures. Around half the states offer online video only from both their lower and upper chambers. A dozen or so legislatures provide both video and audio. Only Rhode Island lacked webcasting, but has its own TV department, according to NCSL’s review.

West Virginia is among 11 or so states solely with audio access. But it also streams committee meetings, and the 15 states that do not include neighboring Ohio, Pennsylvania and Virginia, the NCSL review found.

States have also begun archiving their legislative webcasts. More than 30 do so for their floor proceedings, and nearly half archive committee hearings. West Virginia has yet to add these features. Technical problems also remain an issue. The microphones in House Education, for instance, hang from ceiling and the resulting audio can be hard to hear online. The wireless podium microphone in Senate Judiciary is at least occasionally dead for want of fresh batteries.

The advent of online legislative proceedings also doesn’t render the process completely transparent. After Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin’s mine safety proposal cleared its final House committee hurdle, it idled in that chamber for a week. When it resurfaced, it was accompanied by an amendment that removed one of its provisions and changed several others. Delegates explained that the changes reflected agreements reached among lawmakers, administration officials, industry and labor. But the meetings that yielded this agreement were not public.

Yet, the streaming audio also provides ample evidence of the time legislators spend discussing, debating, amending and voting on bills. The Legislature has also come a long way since the 1960s, when committee meetings were closed to the public.

“We had our sources, or we talked to the chair, or mainly we talked to the limited staff to learn what happened in there,” recounted Karl Lilly, the former newsman and retired veteran of the Senate clerk’s office.

Gradually, the Senate and House opened its committee proceedings. Lilly recalled a reaction to that transition to public meetings that also arose with the debut of online audio streaming.

“There was a concern that the members would play to the media,” Lilly said. “But that never really happened, not to any extent.”

The arrival of technology that allowed regular visits by TV crews to committee meetings provided a similar parallel, Lilly said.

“After a while what happened was, they would get busy and forget about (the cameras),” he said.



West Virginia Legislature Webcasts:

Lawrence Messina covers the statehouse for The Associated Press. Follow him at


Text Only
Latest News
  • twv twins One Hatfield, two actors

    If you shake hands with the cast and crew at Theatre West Virginia after the show, don’t worry if you think you’re seeing double.
    Jacob and James Cline, 12-year-old twins, are a part of the team this year, assisting  with props and portraying Little Troy Hatfield.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Construction begins on Meadow River Rail Trail

    Construction has finally begun on the Meadow River Rail Trail, a recreation project undertaken in a unique partnership between Greenbrier and Fayette counties.

    July 25, 2014

  • AARP reps talk future of Social Security

    The future of Social Security was on the menu at a listening session staged Thursday by AARP West Virginia at the West Virginia School of Osteopathic Medicine.

    July 25, 2014

  • Juvenile petitions sought against teens in Mount Hope B&Es

    The Fayette County Sheriff’s Department is filing juvenile petitions against two Page-area teens after two businesses in the Mount Hope area were broken into early Thursday.

    July 25, 2014

  • US issues 186 mining citations in June

    The Mine Safety and Health Administration says inspectors issued 186 citations at 13 U.S. mining operations in June.

    July 24, 2014

  • Lawsuit filed after Dirty Girl Run canceled

    A lawsuit has been filed against the producers of a run that was canceled in Charleston in which participants were told they wouldn't be issued refunds.

    July 24, 2014

  • Juveniles caught after breaking and entering in Fayette

    The Fayette County Sheriff’s Department is filing juvenile petitions against two teens from the Page area after two businesses in the Mount Hope area were broken into.

    July 24, 2014

  • Saints arrive 1 Saints march into ‘Almost Heaven, W.Va.’

    At 3:54 p.m. Wednesday afternoon the New Orleans Saints’ chartered flight touched the ground at the Greenbrier Valley Airport, and Greenbrier County officially became “Who Dat?” Country. INCLUDES TOUT VIDEO.

    July 24, 2014 3 Photos

  • Broadband panel eyes access to rural areas

    The West Virginia Broadband Deployment Council met far outside its typical Charleston venue Wednesday to hear issues about Internet speeds in some of the state’s most rural regions.

    July 24, 2014

  • Lewisburg official says fuel spill contained, drinking water safe

    Lewisburg’s public works director is confident that a Tuesday afternoon fuel spill 60 miles upriver from the city water system’s intake has been contained and the water is safe to drink.

    July 24, 2014