The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Breaking News

Latest News

May 23, 2011

Lawmaker says multi-delegate districts unconstitutional

BECKLEY — Every West Virginian sends two state senators and one delegate to represent them in Charleston. Unless, as is the case in some districts, they send more. Certain districts have as many as four senators or seven House members representing their constituents.

In the 27th District, which encompasses Raleigh County and much of Summers County, citizens elect five representatives to send to the House in contrast to the people of the 23rd district, who elect only one House representative.

There are 58 districts in West Virginia; 36 of them are single-member districts. While 26 members represent their own district, 22 other districts are split 64 ways.

The constitutionality of those districts and the way members are offered has never been constitutionality tested.

Some lawmakers claim multi-member districts offer a number of disadvantages to the citizens, while offering advantages to incumbents. Republican Delegate Rick Snuffer of the 27th district, poised to benefit from being a part of one of those multi-member districts, says he doesn’t want the advantage.

“I’m considering legal action, as many are across the state,” Snuffer said. “Some don’t think it would be effective, and they are approaching it on a federal level and looking at some different things.”

George Carenbauer, a former chairman of the state Democratic party, has taken an interest in redistricting and has been studying the issue, and passing some of that information on to lawmakers. In one of his presentations, he points out that districts should maintain communities of interest, geographic compactness, respect for political boundaries, racial fairness and approximately equal population.

He said the current districting system isn’t logical and is based on a modified version of a county-based system that didn’t take population into consideration.

“We have a 100 delegates, but we don’t have 100 districts,” Carenbauer said. “It’s all an outgrowth of the original county system kind of morphing and it doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. In fact, it doesn’t make any sense.”

West Virginia, Carenbauer said, is nearly in a league of its own in terms of how many members may be in one district. Ten states have multiple member districts, but of those only three have more than two members. Only New Hampshire and West Virginia assign any district more than three representatives to one district.

“One of the things this causes is to happen is you can say ‘how many delegates can live on your street?’” Carenbauer said. “My brother (in Wheeling) can say two. Somebody in Martinsburg can say one. Somebody in Charleston can say seven. Another part of Charleston can only say one.”

Carenbauer points out numerous advantages to single-member districts. He said not only does it grant equal voting power, but it also lowers the costs of campaigns, eliminates inter-party squabbling, brings representatives closer to the people and increases accountability. He also points out that federal law requires single-member districts in the U.S. and calls multiple-member districts a “political anachronism.”

“From a good-government perspective, the single-member district concept makes sense and it’s time has come ... in West Virginia,” Carenbauer said.

He added that he would recommend an independent body outside of the Legislature to redistrict and eliminate self-interest in the redistricting process, although it is too late to do so for the upcoming special session on redistricting.

The notion that multiple member districts are good for Democrats, the majority party in West Virginia, is also not true Carenbauer said. He points to closer parities in straight-ticket voting, less Democrat-registration in the state and an increasing number of Republicans representing West Virginia at the federal level.

“(Democrats benefiting from multi-member districts) had been true, but that is changing,” Carenbauer said. “West Virginia is changing substantially.”

Snuffer agrees multi-member districts are unconstitutional, and in his fight to even the playing field for “equal representation,” he and others are leaving all options on the table, including legal action.

While the Democratic leadership in the House will have the majority-right to draw districting lines, Snuffer, a Republican, said his issue isn’t about party politics. If Democrats want to draw the lines to benefit their own party, he added, there is no legal argument against it.

“If Republicans want a bigger place at the redistricting table, the answer is simple: win more seats,” Snuffer said.

Currently 40 states have single-member districts, but Snuffer said that doesn’t mean anything either. Snuffer said the argument is about getting all delegates to follow their oath to uphold the state Constitution.

Snuffer said he believes the court’s interpretation of the state Constitution backs up single-member districts.

“Every citizen shall be entitled to equal representation in the government, and, in all apportionments of representation, equality of numbers of those entitled thereto, shall as far as practicable, be preserved,” the constitution states.

Snuffer said that should mean that every citizen appoints the same number of House and Senate representatives in Charleston. Currently, he is considering filing a legal action that would ask the Supreme Court to issue a writ of mandamus requiring that the House redistricting plan provide an equal number of representatives for every voter.

The idea is gaining popularity on both sides of the aisle and from various levels of government. Sen. Joe Manchin, who recently left the position of governor, and current acting Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin have both announced support of single-member districts.

Now that the results of the 2010 Census are in, lawmakers have the ability to redistrict the state to ensure each district represents an equal number of voters.

Snuffer said the idea is to fix the “equal representation issue” early so that legal action is not followed after. If the constitutionality of the districts were challenged after the new districts were drawn, Snuffer said, it would be a greater expense to the taxpayer to redraw the districts again.

Snuffer, who said he is not sure if he will lead or take part in the legal action to ensure districts have an even number of representatives, said he would be satisfied if he could just get a commitment from House Speaker Rick Thompson. Snuffer added that it is not clear if he has legal standing to contest multi-member districts as a representative of a multi-member district.

Single-member districts are not the only solution to making the system pass “constitutional muster,” Snuffer said.

One solution proposed cuts to the number of representatives in both houses by one member. The proposal offers 33 districts with one senator and three House members each.

Snuffer said while he would not vote for any proposals containing multi-member districts, because it would be “bad government,” he would withdraw constitutional arguments as long as constituents in West Virginia get the same number of representatives.

— E-mail:

Text Only
Latest News
  • pittsburgh rally 5,000 rally in Pittsburgh against EPA Clean Power Plan

    The echo of people chanting, “Hey, hey, EPA, don’t take our jobs away” could be heard in downtown Pittsburgh Thursday.

    The voices came from about 5,000 United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) members and their families, along with other unions such as the Boilermakers and the Brotherhood of Electrical Workers International (IBEW), marching through the streets.


    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Alpha plans to idle coal workers

    Approximately 1,100 employees at 11 Alpha Resources-affiliated surface mines, preparation plants and other support operations in southern West Virginia got notice late Thursday afternoon that their jobs could be in jeopardy.


    August 1, 2014

  • New rules to fight black lung disease kick in today

    Joe Massie has spent the last 22 years of his life fighting a disease that takes his breath away, a disease he contracted deep underground in the coal mines over a period of 30 years. 

    Black lung may take away his breath; it has not stilled his voice.

    August 1, 2014

  • target red Zero tolerance Target Red campaign hopes to lessen intersection crashes

    It happens every day.

    A driver hurries on his or her way to work, school or maybe nowhere in particular. Just ahead, a green light turns yellow. With a little more gas, the vehicle just might be able to clear the intersection before that light turns red. Or maybe not. 

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Alpha announces intention to lay off 1,100 surface miners

    The announcement dealt another blow to Appalachia's iconic, but dwindling, fossil fuel industry. The company said 2015 industry forecasts show Central Appalachian coal production will be less than half of its 2009 output. It's due to a combination of familiar factors, Alpha said: competition from cheaper natural gas, weak domestic and international markets and low coal prices.


    July 31, 2014

  • Justice mines have violations in 5 states

    A West Virginia coal billionaire has more than 250 pending violations at mining operations in Kentucky and four other states.

    July 31, 2014

  • VA Greenbrier clinic to remain closed

    The Department of Veterans Affairs Greenbrier County Community Based Outpatient Clinic will remain closed due to ongoing correction of environmental concerns. 

    July 31, 2014

  • prezarrested.jpg Protesters arrested at UMWA Rally in Pittsburgh

    After marching from the David L. Lawrence Convention Center to the William S. Moorehead Federal Building in downtown Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, around 15 United Mine Workers of America (UMW) leaders were arrested.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo 2 Stories

  • Mercer shooting sends one to hospital

     One person has been shot following an apparent altercation in the Montcalm area of Mercer County.

    July 31, 2014

  • UMWA1.jpg More than 5,000 protesting new EPA rules at rally

    Today, 73 buses will bring miners and UMW members to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, for a labor rally and march through downtown Pittsburgh.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo 1 Story