The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Latest News

November 26, 2012

GOP to push drug testing of welfare recipients

CHARLESTON — Mitch Carmichael says the reasoning is simple, logical and fraught with compassion.

If folks reporting to work each day can be put to a drug test, why doesn’t the same practice hold sway for anyone picking up a welfare check or food stamps?

Everywhere he stumped this year in a successful quest for a state Senate seat, the House minority whip found huge support for a Republican-led effort to conduct random drug screens for those on the dole.

Now, as a senator, representing Jackson County in the 4th District, he wants to renew an attempt to force random testing.

At least in the Senate, he has one strong ally — Delegate Craig Blair, a Republican who won a seat in the Nov. 6 election. Blair got the idea rolling a few years back, only to see it die in a House committee.

With the Republicans surging in the balloting and now claiming 46 of the 100 seats in the House, Carmichael sees his chances as vastly improved. After all, five conservative Democrats can align themselves with the GOP bloc and force any legislation onto the floor for a vote, he pointed out.

“And the Senate is a much more conservative body,” he said.

Under the tentative bill, anyone on public aid — excluding, at least for now, those getting an unemployment check — could be ordered to undergo a drug screen. Three failures and the aid ceases.

“Obviously, the concern some expressed is, what do you do about the children?” he said of his campaign treks.

“This is not a mechanism to be punitive. It is intended entirely to be compassionate and help people to get off the drugs and empower them to stay clean and to provide for their families in the proper manner.”

Carmichael acknowledged that some previous backers of such legislation took a hard-line approach to singularly punish the wrong-doers.

“I want to make sure people throughout the state know that is not the intention,” he said.

“It is a compassionate mechanism to break the dependence. The worst thing you can do is leave a child in a drug-infested home. So with this legislation, there are three opportunities to test clean.”

Testing positive the first time allows the recipient to voluntarily seek help. Failing to come clean a second time results in mandatory counseling and this can be achieved in the private sector, even in volunteer settings, such as faith-based groups.

Failing a third time brings the hammer down. Three strikes and you’re out. No more welfare, period.

Is random testing fair, considering that one recipient may be clean as a houndstooth and go through a drug screen, while an habitual abuser never is examined?

“If you happen to be the one that’s completely clean, and you’re being tested and someone’s not, that individual might view it as unfair,” the senator-elect said.

“From a statistical standpoint, it’s completely fair.”

Momentum appears to be shifting in favor of those seeking such testing.

Twenty-eight states are proposing some variation of a testing law. Laws are already on the books in some jurisdictions.

Utah enacted legislation to compel a written questionnaire screening for drug use, while Georgia and Oklahoma passed bills requiring drug tests for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. All recipients must be tested in Tennessee.

“Everywhere I went during the campaign, people were in support of it,” Carmichael said.

“There’s just an overwhelming sense that we’re empowering people to stay home and abuse drugs. There’s a sense of fairness to say, ‘If we have to take a drug test to go to work, then why not take one to stay home?’ That was the biggest applause line. There was overwhelming support for it. I believe if it were put on the ballot, it would pass 75-25.”

— E-mail:

Text Only
Latest News
  • rock VIdeo: Experts dislodge precariously perched remnant of a rockslide

    A highly-trained crew in climbing gear hoisted chainsaws and other specialized equipment high above the road in Hinton Tuesday morning to remove a boulder that hung precariously above a busy intersection.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Preliminary hearing set for Bluefield ‘warlock’

    A Bluefield man who police say used a promise of magical spells to lure children into committing sexual acts with him remains incarcerated at the Southern Regional Jail in Beaver on multiple sexual assault and sexual abuse charges.

    April 23, 2014

  • New River Gorge fire still burning

    Firefighters are still trying to control the fire at Fern Creek along the Endless Wall area of the New River Gorge, according to a press release from the National Park Service on Tuesday.

    April 23, 2014

  • fff Experts help growing entrepreneurs

    John Yates wants to grow potatoes to supply Monroe County schools.
    He’s got a business plan, he can get the equipment and 3 tons of seed potatoes. The land for lease in Sweet Springs is farther from his Ballard home than he’d like, but with a little help, the active duty Army staff sergeant and his sister Rebecca are ready to begin.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Rahall calls meeting on W.Va.’s drug problem

    U.S. Rep. Nick Rahall says he has arranged a roundtable discussion with federal and West Virginia officials on the state’s prescription drug abuse and trafficking problems.

    April 23, 2014

  • Arch Coal reports wider 1Q loss

    Arch Coal Inc. said Tuesday that its first-quarter loss widened as weaker prices and demand cut into its margins, prompting the mine operator to shave its outlook for shipments of coal used in making steel.

    April 22, 2014

  • Former Concord University police officer sentenced on sex charge involving juvenile

    A former Concord University police officer was sentenced Tuesday to a term of 10 to 20 years in prison on a single count of sexual abuse by a parent or custodian.

    April 22, 2014

  • Bly6bH3CYAA6Xdl.jpg-large.jpeg UPDATE: Ill. crew helps fight New River Gorge fire

    An Illinois-based firefighting crew has joined the effort to contain a wildfire in the New River Gorge National River.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Thunderstorms, showers heading our way

    Today’s forecast lurches us a little further toward real spring weather, with scattered showers and thunderstorms possible after 2 p.m.

    April 22, 2014

  • State spring gobbler season to open next week

    The West Virginia Division of Natural Resources says spring gobbler season will open Monday and run through May 24.

    April 22, 2014