The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Latest News

April 1, 2013

At state Legislature, governing debate continues between lawmakers’ parties

CHARLESTON — Whether it comes to seat belts, child care centers or raw milk, the debate over when government should step in continues at the West Virginia Legislature.

Since the session began in February, lawmakers have sparred over scores of measures in committees and on the House and Senate floors. The House’s close 55-44 passage of a stricter seat belt law last week showcased the recurring divide.

Touting saved lives, supporters cited estimates that the bill’s threat of a traffic stop and fine would increase seat belt use by 6 percent. West Virginia now falls below the national rate for seat belt use, and has the fourth-worst road death rate, according to the latest federal figures.

Several opponents embraced the value of seat belts, but argued that whether an adult wears one is a matter of individual choice.

“Mountaineers are always free until a politician decides that you’re not,” said Delegate Jim Butler, R-Mason, during the floor debate.

These recurring tensions aren’t necessarily partisan. The seat belt vote saw both Republicans and Democrats break ranks. Delegate Patrick Lane said such issues can unite the conservative and liberal wings of the Legislature when the question of government involvement arises.

“It’s an interesting coalition that’s been put together around less interference by government in our daily lives,” said Lane, a Kanawha County Republican. “It’s an ongoing debate. ... For some members it’s a guiding principle; for some members it’s issue-to-issue.”

The November election also increased the GOP ranks in the House. That whittled down the Democratic majority on committees often to just one or two seats. Several committees have since seen regulatory measures passed by narrow votes, significantly amended or derailed.

“It’s a very old debate, the rights of the individual versus the rights of the public,” said House Health and Human Resources Chair Don Perdue. “It will continue as long as there’s a republic.”

The Wayne County Democrat’s committee has experienced several examples of this divide. A proposed rule governing child care centers bogged down last month following failed attempts to scale it back. Among other provisions targeted by GOP-led amendments, the rule sought to remove a religious exemption to required child immunizations.

“There are important things of conscience that come before us ... a religious exemption is absolutely critical,” House Minority Leader Daryl Cowles, R-Morgan, said during that debate. “What we’re talking about is the government putting you in a difficult position, putting a parent in a difficult position.”

Perdue’s committee also voted in early March to amend a bill so it allowed raw milk sales. State agriculture officials had reported that raw milk from Pennsylvania caused an illness outbreak in West Virginia and at least two other states last summer. But during that debate, Lane cited how 20 states ban sales and that federal figures show 122 outbreaks between 1993 and 2006. Of the 1,576 people who got sick, 202 were hospitalized.

“In 30 states across the country, out of that large population that has raw milk available to them, 202 people became sick enough from drinking it to go to the hospital,” Lane told fellow committee members. “I think we can make this decision on our own.”

Lane believes the November election results reflected a concern among voters about overreach, whether by legislators or government agencies. He estimated that the rules for the various agencies and programs at the Department of Health and Human Resources, for instance, clock in at 2,500 pages.

“That is law that is made by the administrative agency, and that has expanded over the years,” Lane said. “And as that flows, I think there’s now an understanding among elected members that it has become an over-reach and maybe time for it to ebb back the other way.”

But Lane also said the committees this session have also seen a bipartisan questioning of proposals.

“While sometimes it can be a sort of partisan debate up there, sometimes you’ll have the most conservative and most liberal members of the committee both questioning a similar issue in the bill,” Lane said. “I appreciate that, and I think that creates a better byproduct, when there is that interest in how far does this go, how far should this go, is this really the right policy for our citizens and for the state, and is it going to move us forward or is it going to hold us back?”

— Associated Press writer David Gutman contributed to this report.

1
Text Only
Latest News
  • prezarrested.jpg Protesters arrested at UMWA Rally in Pittsburgh

    After marching from the David L. Lawrence Convention Center to the William S. Moorehead Federal Building in downtown Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, around 15 United Mine Workers of America (UMW) leaders were arrested.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo 2 Stories

  • Mercer shooting sends one to hospital

     One person has been shot following an apparent altercation in the Montcalm area of Mercer County.

    July 31, 2014

  • UMWA1.jpg More than 5,000 protesting new EPA rules at rally

    Today, 73 buses will bring miners and UMW members to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, for a labor rally and march through downtown Pittsburgh.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Kroger restricts pseudoephedrine sales in state

    Supermarket chain Kroger is tightening monthly purchase limits of cold medications that contain pseudoephedrine at its West Virginia stores.

    July 31, 2014

  • ‘Biscuit guy’ makes his mark with anthem at TWV

    The old saying “being at the right place at the right time” couldn’t be more true for Calvin Alexander. Thanks to a salad dressing bottle (and some impressive vocal skills), Alexander was invited to sing the national anthem not once, but twice, at Theatre West Virginia before the opening of “Hatfields and McCoys."

    July 31, 2014

  • legion American Legion posts plan to merge

    To help deal with its decreasing membership numbers, Beckley American Legion Post 70 is planning a merger with Post 32. INCLUDES TOUT VIDEO.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • legal Tort reform group brings message to Beckley

    How can West Virginia create more jobs and have a better business climate, at no cost to taxpayers? Greg Thomas, executive director of the West Virginia Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse (WV CALA), says legal reform is one of the answers to that question.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • Tri-state coal interests rally before hearings

     More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia joined top state elected officials Wednesday to rally against proposed stricter federal pollution regulations for coal-burning power plants.

    July 31, 2014 1 Story

  • Judge in W.Va. asked to delay gay marriage ruling

    Attorney General Patrick Morrisey has asked a judge to postpone ruling on a federal lawsuit challenging West Virginia's same-sex marriage ban until the U.S. Supreme Court reviews a ruling in a similar case in Virginia.

    July 30, 2014

  • Tri-state coal interests rally before EPA hearings

    More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia joined top state elected officials Wednesday to rally against proposed stricter federal pollution regulations for coal-burning power plants.

    July 30, 2014