The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Latest News

February 4, 2013

Local leaders weigh in on allowing gays in Boy Scouts

See BSA's official statement at bottom of story

FAYETTEVILLE — After a recent announcement that the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) is considering doing away with a membership restriction based on sexual orientation, scouting groups near the new permanent home of the National Scout Jamboree are preparing for discussions about the issue.

Rather than dictating any specific policy, the national organization may turn over decision-making power on the matter to local “chartered organizations” that support troops with meeting spaces and other resources. These include churches, civic groups, and educational organizations.

The idea is that locals are best positioned to “accept membership and select leaders consistent with each organization’s mission, principles, or religious beliefs,” said a statement from BSA Director of Public Relations Deron Smith.

When the scouts posted last Monday’s official statement on the matter on Facebook, the post generated over 14,000 comments and over 3,100 “likes.”

The Boy Scouts of America has faced public scrutiny for its exclusive membership practices, given that the group is supported in various ways with taxpayer dollars.

Last July, the organization reasserted its policy of banning gay and nontheistic members, claiming that they are a private organization and exempt from anti-discrimination policy.

They have lost financial support from some private sources over the issue and, by the same token, have been lauded by some religious groups.

- - -

The scout master for Fayetteville’s Troop 179, George Lechalk, says he could see a change in policy affecting membership in both directions.

“Some (parents) may say, ‘Hey, if there is a gay in there, I don’t want my child in there,’ and they might pull their child out. And some may say that to discriminate is wrong and that the Boy Scouts are keeping up with the change of times and now we’ll allow our children to participate,” he said.

“A lot will depend on their individual point of view.”

Lechalk says he hasn’t yet heard any feedback on the announcement from his membership but that he may meet with parents in the future to discuss the issue. He says it will all come down to “following the national recommendation” and continuing to follow policies about preventing and reporting any sexual misconduct.

“This is a real touchy issue and we’re just going to see what comes out of it and move ahead as best we can in training young adults to be men,” he said.

- - -

Dennis Hanson is commander of the Fayetteville American Legion Post 149 — the “chartered organization” for Troop 179 in Fayetteville — and has a grandson in scouting. He says his organization has not discussed the news, either formally or informally.

“That may be a topic of discussion (at our next meeting),” he told The Register-Herald.

“I’m going to let them sort through their thoughts on it. I really haven’t thought about it in detail.”

Elmer Pritt, an adjutant at the post, likewise said it would be inappropriate to discuss the issue until the group has taken a position, but added that the organization has sponsored a Boy Scout troop ever since he can remember.

“We do that with pride and honor and I think they do good work. We couldn’t be more pleased to support the BSA,” he said.

- - -

Some in Fayette County read the announcement with a measure of celebration and relief.

“It is now becoming an organization that I am truly proud that my son is involved in,” said Ami Dangerfield of Fayetteville.

“I think it is great they are being inclusive and not letting an issue that is really not anyone else’s business be a defining factor for the organization.”

But others, like Pastor Mark Wood of Calvary Baptist Church in Oak Hill, saw the development as a sign that the BSA is “heading down the wrong road.”

One big question surrounding the controversy is whether churches will pull their support of the many scout troops that they support across the country.

Wood calls the situation “sad.” Though he is not currently involved in scouting, he is a former scout and scout leader and used to host a troop at one of his churches.

“Going against the true word of God is nothing more than disobedience,” he said. “You can call it ‘tolerance,’ ‘acceptance,’ or any other choice word, but it is that it is.”

- - -

Trey Aliff, Seneca District executive of the Buckskin Council, referred questions to national spokespeople.

The BSA is poised to discuss the membership issue at its biannual national assembly next week.

Last week, the BSA accepted public feedback on the policy change through a telephone hotline. As of Friday it was no longer taking calls but directing comments to its website’s contact page, http://www.scouting.org/ContactUs.aspx, or e-mail, Feedback@Scouting.org.

— E-mail: cmoore@register-herald.com

Text Only
Latest News
  • forum1 VIDEO: Meet the Candidates

    ABOUT THE FORUM:
    The Beckley-Raleigh County Chamber of Commerce hosted a Meet the Candidates forum Thursday morning at the Beckley-Raleigh County Convention Center.

    April 25, 2014 2 Photos

  • Forum: U.S. Senate and House

    U.S. Senate
    The lone candidate for U.S. Senate to attend the Beckley-Raleigh County Chamber of Commerce Meet the Candidate Forum, David Wamsley, described himself as “the most liberal candidate, the most conservative candidate and the most moderate candidate” in the race. Wamsley said he believes each individual issue should be dealt with on its merits and not because of partisan politics.

    April 25, 2014

  • Forum: House of Delegates

    District 28
    Democratic House of Delegates candidates Jeffry Pritt and James Brown focused on issues dealing with the efficiency of the Legislature, crime, infrastructure and taxes.

    April 25, 2014

  • Forum: Board of Education

    Perennial board of education issues of technology, consolidation and truancy were among the questions dealt with Thursday by candidates for a seat on the Raleigh County Board of Education.

    April 25, 2014

  • After being line-item vetoed from state budget, Meadow Bridge to get $50,000 from WVDOE

    After the prospect was initially vetoed by Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin in March, Fayette County School Superintendent Keith Butcher announced this week that the county will indeed receive funds for Meadow Bridge High School after all.

    April 25, 2014

  • ARH, BARH registered nurses to stage one-day strike

    A national labor union announced Thursday that registered nurses at Beckley Appalachian Regional Hospital will join colleagues at Appalachian Regional Hospital in Hazard, Ky., in staging a one-day strike May 1.

    April 25, 2014

  • expressway Coalfields Expressway developments detailed by WVDOT

    A convoy of press, public and politics raised clouds of dust along an unfinished corridor of the long-awaited Coalfields Expressway Thursday during an open tour of the construction zone.

    April 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mercer County firefighters batting three different brush fires

    Firefighters are currently on the scene of at least three brush fires now burning in rural areas of Mercer County.

    April 24, 2014

  • BeverlyMagnumMUG.jpg Woman who attempted to rob bank at gunpoint captured in Tennessee

    A woman who attempted to rob a Bluefield bank at gunpoint has been captured in Tennessee , police said Thursday.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Former federal prison worker pleads guilty to sex offense

    A former federal prison employee pleaded guilty Thursday in U.S. District Court in Beckley to engaging in abusive sexual contact with a female inmate.

    April 24, 2014