The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Montcoal Mine Disaster

April 5, 2011

LESSONS LEARNED

MSHA official says UBB inspired stepped-up inspections

Less than six months after a deadly explosion ripped through the Upper Big Branch mine, killing 29 workers, a federal agency found dangerous conditions inside another Massey Energy installation not far away.

Before the Mine Safety and Health Administration swooped down on the Seng Creek Powellton Coal Mine in Boone County in late September, inspectors commandeered the telephones so the team could get inside the mine before any warning could be sent to the underground bosses.

“When they arrived on this one mining section, they found the ventilation controls not in place, the kind of conditions that lead to explosions, or black lung,” Joe Main, assistant labor secretary for MSHA, told The Register-Herald on the eve of the first anniversary of the UBB tragedy.

“They found the dust was so heavy in the air because of the lack of ventilation that the inspectors could hardly see the huge continuous mining machines when they arrived there.”

Many lessons in safety practices were learned at the expense of the UBB victims, and Main said his agency has methodically implemented them.

One teacher was the special congressional hearing in Beckley, where miners spoke of intimidation at the hands of supervisors for calling attention to unsafe mining practices. Other troublesome aspects pointed to shoddy ventilation methods.

“There were a number of issues, I think, that were raised that were of concern to about everyone who heard it, particularly my agency,” Main told The Register-Herald.

“We made some real adjustments about how we do business, based on those and the issues that have come up.”

MSHA’s investigation likely is to go on beyond the planned June 29 briefing for the public at the mine safety academy in Beckley.

Tentatively, the agency has blamed the explosion on a massive buildup of coal dust, touched off by the blast of a small pocket of methane gas. The likely ignition source hasn’t been identified.

“What we intend is not to blame but to identify all the evidence that was collected and report what that evidence is and what it means,” Main said, when asked if MSHA is pointing fingers at Massey, parent of Performance Coal, which operated the Upper Big Branch installation.

So far, MSHA has conducted seven family briefings, the most ever held during the course of a mine tragedy investigation.

“The evidence is what it is,” Main replied, when asked if the January media briefing painted Massey into a corner of guilt.

“We’ve outlined what we’ve found so far. There’s one thing that is a matter of fact here. Massey Energy was running that mine, was responsible for making sure that health and safety measures were in place to protect those miners. It’s their mine we’re finding these conditions at.”

Asked if Massey were detected to be out of compliance with federal standards, he said, “There’s some conditions that were very troubling that we found.”

A number of Massey officials refused to cooperate in the investigation by taking the Fifth Amendment and not providing certain information, Main said, and that included some high in the company hierarchy, even to the corporate level.

“You can say what you think that means,” the MSHA leader said.

“We’re proceeding with the investigation to collect all the evidence and information. Despite that, we’re going to have a good picture of what was going on at the mine.”

Almost immediately after UBB, the agency embarked on a “special impact inspection program” to target mines that posed especially troubling signs, requiring more than the standard enforcement.

First on that list were mines with a larger potential for explosions and catastrophe, prompting MSHA inspectors to closely examine ventilation, methane, coal dust, and high numbers of citations and orders.

Out of the chute in the accelerated program, MSHA looked at 57 mines, and to date has examined 228 of them, issuing more than 4,000 citations and some 300 orders, Main pointed out.

“And those special inspections have given us even more insight into how some in the mining industry are operating,” he said.

“We believe that there’s a number of mines that operate differently when MSHA is not there, meaning that they do not put into place measures that comply with the law as required. This is not to say that all mine operators do this, because we do not believe that’s the case. We believe that many mine operators throughout the country have sound health and safety programs in place and conduct inspections at the work place to find and fix hazards so miners are not harmed by them. We have some that just clearly don’t do that.”

Among the 57 mines inspected shortly after UBB, the agency forced closure of half a dozen over individual conditions not up to par with federal regulations. Besides the stepped-up inspections, MSHA has retooled its pattern of violations system written into the 1977 safety law that allows it to close a mine over risky conditions. Since the law was approved, no mine has been put on the so-called POV.

But MSHA has beefed up its criteria for getting off the POV and issued notices to 14 mines now caught up in that process, Main said.

“We believe that between now and June (next briefing) will give us time to sort through the evidence and information we’ve collected to provide information that will be worthwhile to the public,” Main said.

Main plans to be at Tuesday night’s memorial in Whitesville for the 29 victims and their families.

“I know of the grief and suffering that families are going through,” he said.

“I can never feel it. It’s something I just know. They’re the only ones that feel the deepest pain out of these tragedies. We owe it to them to find out everything we can about what went wrong. We owe it to them and all the miners in the country to apply those lessons so that no family ever has to go through what they’ve had to go through and to go through the unbearable pain that’s going to last a lifetime.”

— E-mail: mannix@register-herald.com

1
Text Only
Montcoal Mine Disaster
  • UBB report 3 Independent investigation says Upper Big Branch disaster was preventable

    A series of explosions that ripped through the Upper Big Branch mine in Montcoal just over a year ago, killing 29 miners and shocking the nation, were preventable, a report released Thursday stated.

    May 19, 2011 3 Photos

  • Families not surprised Massey was irresponsible

    For the father of one of the victims of the tragedy at Upper Big Branch, hearing investigators say the accident was preventable and largely due to ignoring important safety measures came as no surprise.

    May 19, 2011

  • UBB report provides insight into future of mine safety

    Following an independent investigation into the Upper Big Branch explosion, investigators offered more than 50 suggestions for improving the safety of coal miners underground, and lawmakers across the state and nation have taken notice.

    May 19, 2011

  • MSHA investigation not complete, but mostly in line with independent panel's report

    The public received a few answers to questions about the Upper Big Branch mine explosion Thursday from an independent team, but federal investigators are still completing their investigation.

    May 19, 2011

  • 11 panel findings and suggestions for safety improvements

    As part of the independent investigation of the April 5, 2010, explosion at Upper Big Branch by the Governor’s Independent Investigation Panel, the authors of the report offered the following 11 findings that were accompanied by multiple suggestions for safety improvement.

    May 19, 2011

  • Council may choose outside 4 Beckley mayoral hopefuls

    With the tenure of long-time Beckley Mayor Emmett Pugh ending on Dec. 31, members of the city’s Common Council plan to select an interim mayor at a special Jan. 2 meeting.

    December 13, 2013

  • W.Va. moves to unlicense Upper Big Branch foreman

    West Virginia mine safety officials are moving to revoke the license of an Upper Big Branch mine foreman they say didn’t turn on his methane detector when he was supposed to be checking for the explosive gas.
    The Charleston Gazette says a hearing for Jeremy Burghduff is set for May 15 before the state Coal Mine Safety Board of Appeals.

    April 12, 2012

  • UPDATED: Report also criticizes regulators in UBB mine blast

    The independent investigation that blames the deadliest U.S. coal mine explosion in decades on owner Massey Energy Co. also points out problems with how federal and state regulators policed the West Virginia coal mine where 29 died last year.

    May 19, 2011

  • UBB Scene UPDATED: Families seek justice for fatal UBB mine blast

    Relatives of the 29 men killed in the deadliest U.S. coal accident since 1970 said Thursday the findings of an independent probe confirm what they long suspected, saying Massey Energy Co. cared more about coal than workers’ safety, threatened to fire those who complained and let dangerous conditions build in an ill-fated mine.

    May 19, 2011 3 Photos

  • remember Remembering the 29

    A year after the tragic loss of 29 West Virginia coal miners at a Raleigh County mine, public officials gathered Tuesday evening with victims’ families, rescue workers and others affected by the tragedy.

    April 6, 2011 1 Photo