I remember the day my brother signed up for Selective Service. I don’t remember the date, but I remember the day.
He drove out to our tiny, one-room post office in a corner of the old community store building, went in, filled out the card and came home.
It was all over except for the worrying. The U.S. was in the Cold War with Russia, and sometimes at night I lay in bed and feared the Russians would turn loose an atomic bomb and annihilate us — or worse, that they wouldn’t annihilate us but my brother would be sent to war.
My brother is like many brothers. His heart is bigger than he is. He carried sick calves to the barn, fed our family dog every day without being asked and sneaked a kitten home as a present for my sister because she was desperate to have one.
He believes in God, country and others and practices what he believes. I couldn’t — didn’t want to — imagine him as a soldier fighting a war. We hoped and prayed that because he is the only son in the family that maybe he would not have to serve if called.
Daddy had come close to serving. He got his draft notice and took his physical, but Mom’s pregnancy with my brother prevented him from being called up.
I didn’t stop worrying about my brother being sent to war until President Reagan got the Soviets to sign a treaty to reduce nuclear weapons. Little did I know that wouldn’t stop wars, nor would it stop good brothers like mine from fighting them.
President Jimmy Carter reinstated Selective Service registration in summer 1980. Though the U.S. relies on a 100 percent voluntary military force, the government could call up men who are registered.
Defense Secretary Leon Panetta’s decision to lift the ban on women serving in combat has renewed the debate about whether they should have to register with Selective Service.
They should. Equality is equality, and many women say they want to fill combat roles. They want to be able to compete for the kind of command jobs that will allow them to advance in rank and their careers as men do. Combat roles are where men often earn those career advances.
Some may argue that women shouldn’t have to go to war because they are, after all, women. As the sister of a good man, I don’t think men or women, dog or cat or any of God’s creatures should have to go to war.
Perhaps instead of spending a lot of time and effort figuring out who should be fighting the wars, humankind should spend some effort figuring out how to stop them.
The Washington Post said after Carter reinstated Selective Service registration, a group of men sued, claiming that exempting women was a violation of the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause.
While the U.S. Supreme Court voted 6-3 against the men — citing the combat exclusion — their claim is valid. If women want to enjoy the full fruits of citizenship, they must be willing to pay the full price.
Anything less is asking me whose life has more value — my two nephews’ or my niece’s. I can’t answer that question because all their lives are extremely valuable.
— Young is a Register-Herald columnist. E-mail: ynerissa@frontier.com
© 2013 by Nerissa Young
Columns
Full equality in military service should really mean full equality
The Back Porch
- Columns
-
-
Afternoon nap can reverse burnout from information overload
Are you feeling burned out before supper time? Do you get tired of staring at the computer screen while your eyelids droop?
Or are spring garden chores wearing you out? Maybe the yard work is getting you down?
Well, take a snooze. - Family marks five generations at Concord graduation
- Some phobias are bizarre, but they're no less terrifying
-
Texas senator's prospects re-open 'birther' debate
Maybe it’s time to let a nation of immigrants elect an immigrant as president.
-
The long and storied history of garments and ironing
Like most men, I don’t iron. I never have. Oh, maybe once or twice when I was a kid, but never again.
-
Why does sexual assault in the military persist
Raise your hand if you, like me, have a hard time understanding why the military seems powerless to end sexual assault within its ranks.
-
Events surrounding abortion reveal that ‘it’s complicated’
It’s complicated. That’s the answer adults give to children when they think the answer is something the children won’t understand or the answer is something the adults don’t understand well enough to explain to anyone else — sometimes even to themselves.
-
Appalachian home remedies cure almost everything
Home remedies. You know what I’m talking about. Folk treatments: the odd wisdom of our mountain forebears, herbs and ointments, teas and tonics, powders and salves.
- U.S. produces limited evidence and no good options on Syria
-
Adolescence often traumatic, becoming more complex
Increasingly, they are becoming the “forgotten generation.” They are the teenage sons and daughters of 21st century parents, now stepping uneasily into an unsteady adult world.
- More Columns Headlines
-
Afternoon nap can reverse burnout from information overload



