The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

Breaking News

College Sports

January 6, 2013

NCAA unfair in White ruling

By Mickey Furfari For The Register-Herald

MORGANTOWN — I firmly believe that the NCAA has done an injustice to Pat White.

That organization has ruled that the former West Virginia University quarterback does not hold the all-time record for most rushing yards by a signal-caller.

Why? Because Denard Robinson of Michigan padded his rushing total from a running back position — not as a quarterback — in his final three games.

Robinson finished with 106 yards rushing for Michigan in last Tuesday’s Outback Bowl. A teammate was the starting quarterback then.

The yards boosted the Wolverine’s career total to 4,495 rushing yards on 723 carries. So he wound up with 15 rushing yards more than White’s total and what had been believed an all-time record, a mark that was tied last Wednesday by Florida State’s EJ Manuel in the Orange Bowl against Northern Illinois.

As WVU’s great quarterback from 2005-08, the Alabama native remains the only college quarterback in history to win four consecutive bowl games. He earned numerous honors while here.

White rushed for 4,480 yards as a Mountaineer on 604 carries.

Mike Montoro, WVU director of football communications, appealed the NCAA’s ruling. He strongly suggested that White should still hold the record.

In an e-mail to NCAA officials, Montoro protested that Robinson did not play quarterback — instead, running back — in his last three games and that his rushing yards in those games shouldn’t count in the specific competition.

After Robinson suffered an injury in his right elbow, he played running back in Michigan’s final three games. It clearly was a matter of record.

He gained a grand total of 320 rushing yards in those contests and threw just one pass.

In response to his e-mail, Montoro received a phone call from Gary Johnson, the NCAA associate director of championships and alliances, on Friday.

He said Johnson told him that Robinson’s record stands because he remains listed as a QB on Michigan’s roster and is widely known as a quarterback.

Johnson did say, however, that it will be noted that White got all of his rushing yards as a quarterback.

But that doesn’t satisfy Montoro or White.

“I just don’t agree with the NCAA’s ruling,” Montoro said. “And he (Johnson) knew that when I hung up the phone.

“I just don’t think it is right. But we can’t do anything about it.”

The NCAA knowingly isn’t always right, or so it has seemed to a guy who’s in his 67th year on the WVU sports covering beat.

For example, the NCAA’s periodic practices, in the 1950s and ’60s, of legislating three-year varsity careers was ridiculous.

It was clearly unfair to collegiate athletes of those periods. They had to waste a year of varsity competition.

For years now they all enjoy four-year careers.

Text Only
College Sports
  • Huggins says WVU could be very good team

     Coach Bob Huggins admittedly feels much better about the West Virginia men’s basketball team as it prepares for the 2013-14 season.

    June 17, 2013

  • Bloop hits hurt Miners in first game of twin-bill with Paints

    Chicks may dig the long ball, but on some nights just a few well-placed bloop hits can spell more damage than home runs.

    June 15, 2013

  • Huggins says transfers not isolated case

    Coach Bob Huggins will tell you that losing four players to transfer mode from his West Virginia men’s basketball squad was not an unusual or isolated case.

    June 15, 2013

  • 012612 Bolen.jpg Bolen named assistant coach at East Tennessee State

    When Mountain State University lost its general accreditation last year, head basketball coach Bob Bolen was among many that were left without a job.
    However, as expected, he landed on his feet.
    The lifelong Beckley resident and former head coach at MSU has officially been named an assistant coach at East Tennessee State. The move, which had been rumored for weeks, was announced by the school Friday morning.

    June 14, 2013 5 Photos 1 Story

  • 061413 miners Just who are the 2013 Miners?

    A look at the Propsect League standings gives a clear picture of just how important today’s doubleheader between the Chillicothe Paints and the West Virginia Miners at Linda K. Epling Stadium will be for both teams.

    June 13, 2013 1 Photo

  • 061313 Miners.jpg Miscues cost Miners

    If only earned runs counted, the West Virginia Miners and the Slippery Rock Sliders may still be playing at Linda K. Epling Stadium.

    June 13, 2013 1 Photo

  • Geno in close battle with Sanchez for Jets’ QB spot

    If Geno Smith isn’t the starter this fall with the New York Jets, West Virginia University’s all-time leading passer won’t necessarily be holding a clipboard on the sidelines.

    June 13, 2013

  • 061213 Miners Miners win third straight

    Normally, Dale Davis would have batted left-handed in his seventh-inning at-bat against Slippery Rock reliever Kevin Becker-Mendito. But because of the right-hander’s sidearm motion, the switch-hitting Davis attacked from the right side.

    June 12, 2013 1 Photo

  • Prosecutor says handling of WVU FOIA requests OK

    It wasn’t until about a week ago that I found for certain who is responsible to make sure that the Freedom of Information of Act law is enforced in West Virginia.

    June 12, 2013

  • WVU grad makes donation to OKC tornado relief

    Arizona Diamondbacks managing general partner Ken Kendrick has made a donation of $200,000 to the Mountaineer Athletic Club in the name of the WVU baseball program to the Oklahoma City tornado relief effort.

    June 12, 2013