The Register-Herald, Beckley, West Virginia

College Sports

December 3, 2013

BCS should never have been part of process

If this were 2014, who knows whether Marshall or Rice would be hosting the Conference USA championship game?

One thing is for certain — the game’s site would not be determined the way it was Sunday.

After Florida State wins the national championship in January (yes, that’s my prediction), the BCS will be no more, giving way to the birth of the playoff system most of us have wanted for years. The BCS has been a source of controversy and consternation for a long time now, and is certainly going out with a bang.

Teams that felt worthy of playing for college football’s most coveted prize have been left out, and the potential exists for it to happen one final time next week.

But who would have thought the BCS rankings would have such an impact at the mid-major level as they have in Huntington and Houston?

With East Division champion Marshall and West winner Rice finishing with identical league records, and without a head-to-head matchup to invoke as a tiebreaker, everyone had to wait for the BCS rankings release late Sunday for the site to be announced.

What a dizzying Sunday it proved to be.

Would-be mathematicians dusted off their abacuses in attempts to crack the code.

Jerry Palm, the college football guru at, released some early projections that had Rice ahead of Marshall. Later, after Marshall received votes in the USA Today coaches and Harris Interactive polls — two-thirds of the BCS equation — Palm updated his projections to reflect the Herd at 32 and Rice at 56.

Everything seemed to be pointing toward Marshall hosting its first conference title game in 11 years. Instead, the BCS dropped its C.

Apparently, Palm had been working closely with C-USA to come up with the winner. After all, tickets had to be printed and plans to sell them had to be made as quickly as possible.

Usually, the BCS only worries about computing its top 25. It was even stated in a C-USA release that, “While the BCS standings technically rank 1-25, as that is all that is required for the BCS, the formula (which equally weighs the Coaches poll, Harris poll, and computer polls for a BCS average) can be extended to determine the relative positions of teams.”

In other words, Palm did C-USA a favor in agreeing to help.

I can just hear Palm reacting with a “really?” when the C-USA asked for his help in solving the dilemma.

In the end, Rice won out because Palm’s earlier projections did not take into account the computer positions of teams that did not receive votes in either of the human polls — e.g. Rice.

Palm was even quoted in the C-USA release that the formula used for breaking the tie “doesn’t match the formula I use for my ratings on, which serve a different purpose, but I believe it was absolutely appropriate and fair.”

Translation: “Rice is your winner. Now, please, leave me alone. Auburn just beat Alabama in the greatest finish to a college football game ever. I have more important things going on.”

I don’t think C-USA acted to job Marshall. At least, not intentionally. I just think the league didn’t think it through. It is clearly spelled out that “BCS ranking (i.e. average computer ranking) would be used to determine host.”

That’s pretty simple. But when it came down to it, the rules were altered at the absolute wrong time.

Far be it for me to say the league dropped the ball, but C-USA made Bill Buckner look like Willie Mays on this one.

The BCS should never have been involved in the first place. Unless there is a Northern Illinois or Boise State involved, the BCS is useless to a mid-major conference. Go to points scored in conference games, or points allowed, or attendance, or mascots — anything other than the BCS. Even the Big 10 — a BCS conference — waits to use the rankings as a fifth tiebreaker when trying to determine a division champion.

If C-USA isn’t good enough for the BCS, then the BCS should not have been good enough for C-USA.

— E-mail: gfauber@ and follow on Twitter


Text Only
College Sports
  • 042314 trickett Mountaineers have benefited from incoming football transfers

    Recruiting in college football seems to get more and more attention every season. Websites like and stalk the high school sidelines and blow up potential recruits’ cell phones in search of the latest information. But there’s one important aspect that often goes ignored — transfers.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • WVU baseball pounds Terps

    The offense had 16 hits and sophomore left-hander Ross Vance struck out six as the West Virginia University baseball team routed Maryland 14-2 on Tuesday evening at Hawley Field.

    April 22, 2014

  • Crutchfield not interested in Division I job

    You would think Jim Crutchfield would be a great candidate for a head basketball coach’s job at an NCAA Division I university.
    But the Clarksburg native keeps saying that he’s perfectly content in that role at West Liberty, a Division II powerhouse. His 10-year record there is an absolutely amazing 272-49. Significantly, 10 of those defeats came in his first year at the West Liberty helm.

    April 22, 2014

  • Stepping up: Kelly racking up wins for Lions

    Sundays have become red-letter days for Chris Kelly.

    April 22, 2014

  • Paul Popovich, now 73, wishes he were playing baseball today

    If you’re a longtime baseball fan, you may recall Morgantown’s Paul Popovich.

    April 22, 2014

  • Hiring an interim while waiting on D’Antoni would be an injustice

    The search for Marshall’s new men’s basketball coach remained in a holding pattern over the Easter weekend while the Los Angeles Lakers put off their decision on coach Mike D’Antoni’s future until this week.

    April 21, 2014

  • 041914 gibby WVU trying to find speed on defense

    Tony Gibson took over as West Virginia’s new defensive coordinator over the winter with the goal of trying not to do too much to rock the boat. As the fourth coach to hold that spot in as many years, the Van native — in his second stint as a Mountaineer assistant — knew that his players needed some stability.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Turnbull’s tenure dominates WVU wrestling history

    Did Oliver Luck really do a thorough job in deeply evaluating Craig Turnbull’s 36-year career as wrestling coach before firing him?

    April 17, 2014

  • WVU’s top football prospects working out for NFL teams

    As we draw ever closer to the NFL Draft, the prospect workouts for teams are picking up steam for former Mountaineers. Both running back Charles Sims and defensive end Will Clarke have a busy road ahead.

    April 17, 2014

  • 041714 millard Kickoff time set for WVU-Alabama

    West Virginia football fans can now start counting down to the exact minute, instead of just the day.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo